I think Odrick is a step down from Starks but IMO If Starks comes back it will be for a deal similar to what Soliai got. 2 years 12 mil.
Kendall langford got a similar deal (6m per year) from STL but it was for 4 years with 12 mil guaranteed.
Red Bryant (Seattle) signed a 5 yr 35m deal last year.
Starks is very good but there are better DT's avaialble according to PFF. Henry Melton would be a huge FA pickup. He is among the best in the league.
A former Dolphin draftee, Kevin Vickerson has a +4.0 rating compared to Starks' +3.5 but will probably get less money.
Jason Jones (Seattle) had a +5.6 rating. Vance Walker (ATL) had a +7.6
I think there are plenty of options this year in FA for DT's with a possibility to upgrade for short money.
Tony McD is also a FA this year and has been a huge part of the rotation. I think Odrick could take over for him in the rotation but I would not depend on him as a full time starter.
FA seems to be deep in quality OT, DT, WR, FS & CB. Beyond that it is not a bad market for DE & OG.
(I guess you were right ChyrenB...about using FA for C
By way of comparison...
Sean Smith had a -3.5 rating.
Players at the top of the FA list.....
#1 Adam Jones +11.1 (Kevin Coyle pupil)
Sam Shields +10.9
Terrance Newman +8.6 (Kevin Coyle pupil)
Sheldon Brown +7.5
Chris Houston +7.4
There are many that outplayed all of our CB's. (Brian McCann from Miami had a +1.3) 23 players had a positive grade.
.....................................................................................
“I'm here" You're welcome!" - Kenny Powers