Poll

59 votes were received.
All visitors can vote.

Which of the Four Rookie QBs will be the most successful at the end of the first season

	Andrew Luck
	Robert Griffin III
	Ryan Tannehill
	Brandon Wheeden

---

At the end of the season, ASSUMING ALL FOUR QBS START

Which will be the most successful?

As you can see, my vote, the first, is for Tannehill.

Thats tough because it depends on the position the Teams that drafted them place them in.

too easy. andrew luck

________________________________________________________
The beatings will continue until morale improves.

I went ahead and voted for Tannehill under the assumption that he starts. Part of the reason, is that I assume that the Dolphins have more talent around him and a system and pace that could lead to a lot of points. The defense figured to be better too. Of course, judging by what we have seen so far in the preseason, it doesn't seem like that will be the case. I hope they put it together.

Tannehill's first game was against second third team Defense
I see sme promise, but not sure he is ready, but as a whole we don't look good, so maybe we give him a try and play for Barkley

Luck has better talent than T-hill. I'm sorry but that's just non-homer truth.

Did you see him tonight. I only saw one series but they replayed a pick six he threw earlier and he didn't look so good on that one series, Luck that is.

Tannehill can't get the ball past the LOS without it getting batted down. At lear Luck can get it far enough for a pick six.

------------------------------------------------------------

Miami Dolphins. Always Perfect.

Evan Silva ?@evansilva
Rookie Andrew Luck's 11 preseason drives so far have produced 38 points. The #Jets have had 23 possessions and scored 9 points.

________________________________________________________
The beatings will continue until morale improves.

I have some crazy wistful hope that someday, you guys will be able to get your point across without calling each other names.

I also hope for world peace, and the end of all suffering in the universe.

That kid is the real deal

chatafkup Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> That kid is the real deal


Which kid?

Define successfull.

better QB rating or better team record?

.....................................................................................
“I'm here" You're welcome!" - Kenny Powers

Eesti, meaning like Cam Newton was successful last year. He went to the ProBowl. That was more a compliment to him than his team. I mean stuff like QB ratings.

Anyway, with Tannehill, the question is sheerly academic.

LOL. I mean. It's not like we have, FOR SURE, the greatest TEAM in the NFL. If that were true, I could see your point that maybe Tannehill should not be given credit when he's playing on a powerhouse team.

Of the four teams, I guess Washington (RGIII) is probably the most solid but some would say Indianapolis ((Luck)depends on whether they played like Crap for Luck and/or they need a magic ingredient such as a great QB like Luck or Manning to magically convert them to a great team). Few would say Cleveland (Wheeden's home) and even less would say Miami.

Luck
RGIII
Wheeden
Tannehill


My choice for the phins (Kirk Cousins) is looking damn good in DC.

Chren were you the only one that voted for weeden man.?

Luck, hands down.

Luck was awesome against the Steelers.

The colts team looks a lot better than I expected!

When I look at what they have put together, it removes all excuses for the FINS being ready, due to changes in system.

The colts started over wholesale and look good!

SamSam, re-read the first message in this thread.

It is tough competition and Luck will be hard to beat. Tough question as well.

Too many variables...at WR and OL. Luck has a veteran franchise receiver and his college TE.

RT has ?????

I will say that we will look much better in the reg season with some game planning. We are strictly vanilla so far. No Reggie Bush playing WR. Sets with Bush and Lamar..etc.

.....................................................................................
“I'm here" You're welcome!" - Kenny Powers

I want to modify my list:

LUCK
Griffin III
Foley
Wheeden
Cousins
Tannehill
Davis - playing damn well in Atl

Just FYI...I think Indy released something like 15 starters so they are in a bigger rebuilding mode than we are. They were just talking about it on NFLN yesterday.

What are the limits on the "bet"?

Plays a minimum of 12 games?

cause half the QB's on the list above (mizzou) prob won't even see the field this year unless as injury replacement for a few games. Not to mention they weren't even in the discussion.

What no mention of Russel Wilson?

.....................................................................................
“I'm here" You're welcome!" - Kenny Powers

Wow right now 5 rookies might be starting opening week. 6 if Vick keeps thinking he's a fullback. This was a pretty good qb class.

ChyrenB Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> SamSam, re-read the first message in this thread.


OK thanks chren...Gotcha.

" Tannehill can't get the ball past the LOS without it getting batted down. At lea(st) Luck can get it far enough for a pick six."
The first part of this statement is rather foolish hyperbole presented as "fact", the second part does not support your implication. Why did you even bother?

Rick



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 08/21/2012 12:44PM by dolphan4545.

No. I did, as well.

Rick

RT will have best season...and it's because we have the most talent around him. The key to making this happen is to get everyone on the same page...and we ain't there yet.