Can't deny the obvious. Couple that with consistently whiffing in R2 3 4 and there's no wonder why we're constantly "rebuilding."

Truth is, we haven't completed anything in years...

I'm tellin ya...Like a dog chasin its tail.

So whos the biggest miami dolphins 1st round pick bust?

I vote for

1. Sammie smith.

Yatil

As far as talent and been able to play in the NFL..Yatil played a few games after the injury. He had mad talent.

Sammie smith was a fumbling machine.

DolfanKing Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> > 1971 No Selection
> 1970 No Selection
>
>
> So much for the first round yeilding immediate
> impact.


Casserly had a great point on NFLN.

Said he researched 2nd round picks over the last decade.

said only 50% were starting in the NFL today.

More reason to go BPA and forget need.

BigNastyFish Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Can't deny the obvious. Couple that with
> consistently whiffing in R2 3 4 and there's no
> wonder why we're constantly "rebuilding."

Yeah...we've been "rebuilding" with toothpicks and wet toilet paper.

worst ever?
sammie smith at least had his moments. yatil couldn't help it, he got hurt all the time.
we've had some straight up stinkers who could play at all---billy milner? jamar fletcher? eric kumerow? and more.

________________________________________________________
The beatings will continue until morale improves.

berkeley223 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> worst ever?
> sammie smith at least had his moments. yatil
> couldn't help it, he got hurt all the time.
> we've had some straight up stinkers who could play
> at all---billy milner? jamar fletcher? eric
> kumerow? and more.


If Don Shula were as good a GM as he was a coach he'd have never lost a game.

Worst ever?

Eric Kumerow is up there. Billy Milner. Yatil Green, certainly. Taking LB Eddie Moore when the scouting staff wanted Anquan Boldin was pretty bad. This one certainly isn't the worst in terms of talent, because he at least played for 8 years, but the circumstances make it the biggest mistake ever. Jamar Fletcher. We already had Surtain and Madison, and the scouts wanted Drew Brees. But, we took Fletcher. That one takes the cake.

yeah dolfan mark....i was scratching my head over the jamar fletcher pick because we had madison and surtain.

Tedd Ginn?

dolfanmark Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Worst ever?
>
> Eric Kumerow is up there. Billy Milner. Yatil
> Green, certainly. Taking LB Eddie Moore when the
> scouting staff wanted Anquan Boldin was pretty
> bad. This one certainly isn't the worst in terms
> of talent, because he at least played for 8 years,
> but the circumstances make it the biggest mistake
> ever. Jamar Fletcher. We already had Surtain and
> Madison, and the scouts wanted Drew Brees. But, we
> took Fletcher. That one takes the cake.

It would probably take less time to list all the good picks...


But since you put in the effort already, lets not forget Jackie Shipp and John Bosa!

montequi Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Tedd Ginn?


Please monte for worst pick of all time?

Not even close. And am fond of ginn and his two returns for the win against the jets.